This analysis by By Martin Nicholson and Peter Lang was published 12 August in Brave New Climate. Download the printable PDF here. [An addendum on wind farm and solar construction rates, by Dave Burraston]
Edit: Here are some media-suitable ‘sound bytes’ from the critique, prepared by Martin. Obviously, please read the whole critique below to understand the context:
- They assume we will be using less than half the energy by 2020 than we do today without any damage to the economy. This flies in the face of 200 years of history.
- They have seriously underestimated the cost and timescale required to implement the plan.
- For $8 a week extra on your electricity bill, you will give up all domestic plane travel, all your bus trips and you must all take half your journeys by electrified trains.
- They even suggest that all you two car families cut back to just one electric car.
- You better stock up on candles because you can certainly expect more blackouts and brownouts.
- Addressing these drawbacks could add over $50 a week to your power bill not the $8 promised by BZE. That’s over $2,600 per year for the average household.